Die Falle der künstlichen Intelligenz – Rezension: Eric Sadin, Le Désert de nous-mêmes: Le tournant intellectuel et créatif de l’intelligence artificielle

english french german 

According to French philosopher Éric Sadin, a specialist in technology, the launch of ChatGPT on November 30, 2022, marks a profound turning point with far-reaching social and cultural consequences. AI systems claim to be capable of taking on more and more fundamental human capabilities, such as the production of language, images, and videos, but in reality, they are limited to the existing content used to train them.

Sadin’s direct critique targets every aspect of the systems that are being presented to us as AI. First and foremost, he questions how they function and their claim to produce intelligent content. ChatGPT and its counterparts cannot produce anything new; at best, they create new content based on the statistical frequency of word combinations. They lack the imagination that characterizes human beings, but the AI systems’ claim to be able to imitate it provokes Sadin’s scathing criticism.

The title of this book literally translates to “The Desert of Our Self,” which refers to our own fault—one for which Sadin reproaches us—because as soon as we consult AI, we abandon our creativity, our imagination, or even our sociability in favor of a machine that can only calculate content, but not imagine it.

He equates utilitarianism with a disease. In his view, this leads to our own alienation. The emergence of ChatGPT heralds a new era of artificial domination, a decoupling of humans from their world, and a negation of our very selves. In other words, automation neutralizes our abilities and seeks to take control of our creative capacities. Sadin speaks of our necrosis; avoiding it now would be the only way to preserve humanism.

See also: “”Review: Éric Sadin, La vie spectrale. Thinking About the Age of the Metaverse and Generative AI

Sadin criticizes ChatGPT & Co. for suggesting that mechanical production can take on human traits, even though its output is based solely on associations and correlations. And Sadin refers to Paul Valéry, who stated at the Collège de France: “To create is to choose.” This unpredictability, which characterizes the creative act, is beyond the reach of ChatGPT & Co. Henri Bergson expressed a similar idea in *Creative Evolution* (1912), describing a creative impulse that brings forth the new and affirms freedom with every act—an impulse that Sadin contrasts with the language of machines: “We recognize the gigantic reductionist machine that is tainting our imagination…” (p. 48) and he recalls Charles Péguy, who declared: “There is something worse than a bad thought: having a preconceived thought…”

Sadin aims to show that the much-praised linguistic models thrive solely on constant plagiarism, through which they seek to prove their intelligence to us. He echoes Jacques Lacan: “When man forgets that he is the bearer of speech, he no longer speaks… When man no longer speaks, he is spoken.” Capitalist linguistics thus finds itself in the crosshairs of his relentless critique. “Generative artificial intelligence” would, above all, destroy our capacity for judgment. The evidence Sadin cites—from Günther Anders to David Graeber—underpins the theoretical foundation of his reflections.

According to Sadin, the most serious consequences will be felt as soon as AI is used in the field of education. Learning is linked to curiosity, the discovery of new things, and the willingness to change. With AI and the accompanying optimization of learning processes, utilitarianism becomes the sole guiding principle, supplanting the capacity for judgment, undermining social behavior, fostering self-sufficiency, and severing ties with our loved ones.

Sadin strongly opposes the automated generation of images and videos, which bypasses reality and leaves it to machines to interpret it. He accuses reality of being subjected to mathematical abstraction.

In the chapter “A World of Illusions,” Sadin traces the history of “social media,” which encourages the spread of pain, resentment, and hatred—and even “fake news”—thereby destroying the foundation of shared values.

The third chapter, “Toward the Complete Automation of Work,” is subtitled “A Crime Against Homo faber”: “How can we ignore the storm sweeping away professions that require highly developed cognitive skills? ” (p. 123) Sadin also takes aim at the distribution of iPads and laptops in schools, which are ill-suited to stimulating the curiosity of children eager to discover the world, but instead ruthlessly subject them to the long-awaited “digital transformation” industry (p. 124 ff.). Sadin paints a bleak picture of the future of the school system, which replaces teachers—who impart knowledge and encourage participation in collaborative projects—with AI applications, thereby stifling children’s abilities before they even have a chance to develop.

See also: Review: Oliver Held, ChatGPT in History Class

Sadin goes even further and sees in AI’s increasingly intrusive claims a new “TOTAL POWER ” (p. 177), describing an omniscient power that intrudes everywhere, influences our actions, and thereby acquires political power. This is a process of dehumanization that relieves us of all effort and fosters the growing stupefaction of humanity. (p. 181

Creativity, autonomy, and even freedom are left by the wayside when we rely on AI. Our imagination and ingenuity atrophy when we abandon them to machines. Sadin strongly opposes this trend, which is not a democratically decided societal project but simply the expression of technical ambitions for power, and which requires a resolute defense of human capabilities.

One might think that Sadin is going too far with his diatribe, especially now that we’re being led to believe that the economy was just waiting for AI and that students are benefiting from new dimensions of learning thanks to it. But Sadin does not see these positive aspects. He takes aim at the ideology behind AI, at its desire to take control of our thoughts and decisions, and above all at our willingness to follow the siren call of AI. Technology beckons, and we abandon our freedom and our humanism—that is how one might summarize Sadin’s arguments. Is he, then, a voice in the wilderness, standing alone against all those who praise the new reality of AI? Not really, because with his nuanced reflections and deductions, he offers an important alternative to the overly one-sided praise of AI. His book is a significant contribution to the debate on the social consequences of the AI craze.

Übersetzungen mit der Unterstützung von www.deepl.com.

Eric Sadin, Le Désert de nous-mêmes: Le tournant intellectuel et créatif de l’intelligence artificielle, Paris: L’Èchapée 2025.  19 €

> Die Beiträge unserer Redaktion zur KI – www.france-blog.info

Rezension: Hugues Cologan, Le Coup d’avance

french german 

Hugues Cologan
Le Coup d’avance
Arles: Portaparole 2023
144 pages / 18,00 euros
ISBN 978-2-37864-072-9